A Starter Guide on Designing for Additive Manufacturing

Additive Manufacturing Is for Everyone — Not Just Big Companies

Designing for additive manufacturing — DFAM starter guide — Stratnel

Additive manufacturing across industries — Stratnel

Are additive manufacturing methods meant only for high-end product companies like large aerospace, automotive, or medical devices companies — and hobbyists? Not any more. It is getting to be more mainstream in almost all industries regardless of complexity, sophistication, segment, or size.

Why is it that some industries are benefitting more from additive manufacturing than others? One big reason is that they have learnt the lessons to design differently for 3D printing. Here we will talk about how product designing processes have to be different.

The set of "Design Principles" traditionally used must be revisited to take full advantage of additive manufacturing and 3D printing.

Traditional Design Principles Will Not Work with 3D Printing

The following traditional design principles will not apply when you are designing to leverage 3D printing.

Existing designs can be tried for additive manufacturing effectiveness. This approach is most likely to fail — because the existing design was designed for traditional manufacturing methods.

Avoid complex shapes in products; use simple geometries for DFM considerations.

Complex shape that is hard to machine but straightforward to 3D print — Stratnel

Traditional manufacture may require a lot of machining for a complex shape like this — but with 3D printing this product is straightforward to design and print.

Doing multiple iterations to optimize design is very time consuming and expensive in traditional manufacturing. Since additive manufacturing does not involve expensive tooling, you could run iterations to optimize your design within a short span compared to traditional methods.

Using multiple materials in one part is almost impossible without very complex manufacturing and/or assembly methods — additive manufacturing changes this entirely.

Standard parts are better than custom parts for subtractive manufacturing. In additive manufacturing, parts are made anew every time. There is no such thing as a 3D printed "standard part."

Additive manufacturing aficionados have to give up their fixation on materials. Statements such as "all our parts have to be in aluminium only" are a constraint that does not apply. Additive manufacturing can achieve high rigidity through composites — carbon fiber reinforcement is very much a reality. Open minds will pave the way not only for newer materials, but also gain weight reductions as a bonus.

There is this standard notion that "3D printing is expensive." It will not be expensive if we consider the total applied cost — which includes tooling costs, lead times, inventory carrying costs, factory footprint savings, productivity levels, and more.

All these may appear difficult to the uninitiated — but the benefits are substantial. Imagine the advantages of replacing an engineering process costing $800 and taking 10 days with another more elegant solution that costs only $200 and takes only 2 days. If such economies are in fact realisable, how many different processes in your workplace could you deploy additive manufacturing to gain competitive advantage?

The Drill Jig — A Design Example

Let us talk specifics. Consider a drill jig for drilling axial holes in a spherical object in all three axes. The idea is that one first drills a hole by centering the sphere in a conical locator, locates the first drilled hole on two pins resting on a V-block, and repeats the same exercise in another orientation for the third axis.

Drill jig concept — spherical object with axial holes in three axes — Stratnel

Traditionally made and assembled drill jig — Stratnel

A traditionally made and assembled jig may look like this. This design is representative and will need further work to ensure clamping and other requirements.

A 3D printed jig will be a lot easier to make with just two parts:

A structure to locate the parts, the pins, and the jig bush.
The jig bush itself.

3D printed drill jig — two-part design — Stratnel

Design Steps for Additive Manufacturing

The design steps in Fusion 360 are as follows:

Create the base with the conical locator and the V-groove for the pins, and locate the bush at the correct position. Generate a ring body around the bush to house the bush.

DFAM step 1 — base with conical locator, V-groove, and ring around bush — Stratnel

Generate the starting area of the pillars on the top surface of the base plate. Generate a plane normal to the base and at 45° to the edge of the plate, where you can draw the spline path for the pillar. Create a plane normal to the spline path at the end of the spline, close to the jig bush.

DFAM step 2 — pillar starting area and spline path — Stratnel

Generate a new body by lofting the starting area of the pillars and the profile at the termination end, along the spline path. Generate a circular pattern of the new body to get the four pillars.

DFAM step 3 — lofted pillars with circular pattern — Stratnel

Combine the bodies — the base plate, the ring around the jig bush, and the pillars — into one body. Convert to a component, and the job is done.

DFAM step 4 — combined final jig body — Stratnel

Shift in Design Paradigm for 3D Printing

Designers have to be innovative and think out of the box when designing for 3D printing. This is new learning and challenges the traditional concepts learnt so far by designers. Additive manufacturing does challenge traditional manufacturing — and designers have to make suitable changes in their thinking in order to be successful.

K Padmanabhan

CEO, Stratnel Technologies LLP

With over 40 years in manufacturing — from tool design to leading a multinational as CEO for 18 years, to co-founding Stratnel and building its additive manufacturing capabilities — he brings first-principles thinking to every process challenge.

Found this useful?

Share Your Thoughts

Have a question or a perspective to add? Write to us below — we read every message, and may feature selected responses in a future post.

Thank you — your message has been sent. We will review it and may feature it in a future post.

A Starter Guide on Designingfor Additive Manufacturing

Additive Manufacturing Is for Everyone — Not Just Big Companies

Traditional Design Principles Will Not Work with 3D Printing

The Drill Jig — A Design Example

Design Steps for Additive Manufacturing

Shift in Design Paradigm for 3D Printing

A Starter Guide on Designing
for Additive Manufacturing